Most BigCommerce SEO articles rehash surface-level tactics—update your metadata, improve URLs, enable breadcrumbs, etc. These are easy wins, but they do almost nothing to address the deeper technical limitations that determine whether a BigCommerce store can pass Core Web Vitals or rank competitively.

What actually matters for SEO on BigCommerce is not the checklist items—it’s the platform’s performance constraints and how well you work around them. Speed, rendering, image delivery, JavaScript weight, and server response times are the true deciding factors. If you’re not addressing these, your SEO effort is capped long before content or metadata even come into play.

This article dives into the practical, real-world challenges of BigCommerce SEO and the solutions used by developers and agencies who specialize in technical BigCommerce implementations.

---

Why BigCommerce SEO Requires Technical Awareness

BigCommerce is an Open SaaS platform designed for stability, security, and scalability. But the tradeoff is that certain parts of the rendering pipeline are not fully under your control. For SEO, this means you must work within the platform’s boundaries—or circumvent them using modern architecture like headless commerce.

The main constraints include:

• Lack of native next-gen image support
• Heavy JavaScript bundles from Stencil
• Limited critical CSS control
• Slow TTFB during peak traffic
• App-based scripts inflating INP
• Difficulty reducing render-blocking assets

These are not problems a typical SEO checklist can fix. They require architectural decisions, theme refactoring, or a move to a headless setup.

---

1. BigCommerce Does Not Natively Serve Next-Gen Images (WebP/AVIF)

This is one of the single biggest performance bottleneck on BigCommerce. Stencil themes always serve the original image file—usually a large JPG or PNG—without automatic resizing or compression. On mobile devices, this is devastating to LCP scores.

A 1200px banner that could be compressed down to a 120 KB WebP frequently ends up being a 600 KB PNG. Multiply this by hero banners, category headers, and product cards, and you can see why BigCommerce stores often struggle to load quickly.

Practical Solutions

Use ImageKit, Cloudinary, or Cloudimage

This is the preferred professional solution. These CDNs intercept your image URLs, optimize them on demand, and deliver them in modern formats. This alone can cut total image weight by up to 70%.

Use WebDAV for manual WebP on key assets

Some stores aren’t ready for an external image CDN. In these cases, you can upload optimized WebP versions of banners or hero images into WebDAV and reference them directly in your templates. It’s manual, but effective for pages that matter most.

Headless (Catalyst / Next.js) for automatic optimization

Next.js provides transformation, compression, and resizing through its built-in image component:

import Image from "next/image";

For many brands, this alone justifies a headless approach, as image optimization becomes automated and globally cached.

---

2. Stencil’s JavaScript Bloat Slows Interaction and Rendering

Stencil themes tend to accumulate JavaScript over time—both from the theme itself and from the apps merchants install. Review widgets, personalization apps, tracking pixels, and chat plugins all load their own bundles. The result is common: a megabyte or more of JS that must be parsed before the page becomes interactive.

This directly affects INP and overall user experience.

How to Fix It

Audit and remove legacy JS

Most Stencil themes include scripts that are no longer used, such as old sliders, galleries, or jQuery plugins. Removing these can significantly reduce script weight. This requires a developer to execute a very careful audit of your theme’s assets.

Defer non-critical scripts

Scripts that aren’t essential for initial rendering should load with defer so they don’t block the parser.

<script defer src="/js/custom.js"></script>

Catalyst reduces JS by design

Catalyst (the official BigCommerce headless framework) loads dramatically less JS because much of the rendering happens on the server. This leads to faster interaction, better input responsiveness, and significantly improved metrics.

---

3. BigCommerce TTFB (Time to First Byte) Can Be Slow

Since BigCommerce dynamically renders Stencil pages on the server, TTFB can vary. When traffic is high or when templates are complex, TTFB increases. Even 500–800ms TTFB creates a bottleneck that drags down LCP.

Google evaluates TTFB as part of Core Web Vitals now, so this matters more than ever.

Solutions

Lighten your templates

Reduce deeply nested Handlebars calls, simplify conditional logic, and eliminate unnecessary partials.

Static Generation via Headless

Headless storefronts let you pre-render pages at build time and serve them statically from the edge. This turns TTFB into a near-non-issue:

• 10–30ms TTFB
• Global caching
• Faster crawling and indexing

This is one of the biggest benefits of headless commerce.

---

4. CSS Bundles in Stencil Are Large and Unscoped

Stencil themes typically compile everything into a single CSS file. This makes maintenance simple but performance poor. Unused CSS slows parsing and postpones rendering of critical content. Combined with large hero images, this increases CLS and pushes LCP into the red.

Solutions

• Inline critical CSS for above-the-fold elements
• Purge unused CSS with PurgeCSS
• Reduce or remove global utility classes you don’t use
• In headless builds, rely on framework-level CSS splitting

Even small CSS changes here can move LCP scores dramatically.

---

5. BigCommerce’s Default Schema.org Implementation Is Good, But Not Enough

While BigCommerce does auto-generate schema for basic products, it often falls short for:

• Variant-level attributes (GTIN, MPN)
• Custom product fields
• Landing pages
• Collections or curated groupings
• FAQ or educational content

Additionally, some apps inject redundant JSON-LD, accidentally creating duplicates that confuse search engines.

Solutions

• Remove duplicate schema manually
• Add custom JSON-LD for PDPs and PLPs
• Inject structured data into custom templates
• Headless: dynamically generate schema per page using components

Schema is one of the highest ROI technical SEO tasks—especially for product-rich catalogs.

---

When Stencil Is Good Enough vs. When You Need Headless

Not every business needs a headless architecture. Stencil can perform very well when optimized correctly. The key is understanding where the line is.

Stencil works well if:

• Your business doesn’t need ultra-custom UX
• Your theme is clean and modern
• You can manage images manually
• You only need moderate performance improvements
• You don’t rely heavily on dynamic content

Many stores achieve Lighthouse scores in the 80–90 mobile range with enough refinement.

Headless becomes necessary when:

• You want automated image optimization
• You need complex product presentation
• You want near-instant loading from global edge networks
• You have heavy personalization or dynamic content
• Your marketing team needs layout flexibility
• You’re hitting the limits of Stencil’s JS and CSS structure

Headless fundamentally changes what’s possible on BigCommerce. It removes the largest bottlenecks—images, CSS, JS, TTFB—and gives full control over rendering.

---

A Modern High-Performance eCommerce Stack

A proven architecture many high-growth brands use:

• Frontend: Next.js (Catalyst or custom)
• CMS: Contentstack, Sanity, Storyblok
• Commerce: BigCommerce (catalog + checkout)
• Images: ImageKit or Cloudinary
• Search: Typesense or Algolia
• ERP: NetSuite with Celigo automation
• Email: Omnisend
• Hosting: Vercel or Netlify

This combination produces exceptional speed, SEO performance, and maintainability.

---

The Advanced BigCommerce SEO Checklist

Below is a refined list of tasks that move the needle the most:

• Serve WebP/AVIF (CDN or headless)
• Reduce JS by removing legacy Stencil modules
• Defer all non-critical scripts
• Inline critical CSS for hero sections
• Use PurgeCSS to trim global styles
• Improve TTFB by removing complex template logic
• Add complete structured data for products and landing pages
• Move key landing pages to static generation
• Replace heavy third-party apps with lightweight integrations
• Audit and compress all image assets

These optimizations create meaningful, measurable improvements—not just better Lighthouse scores, but a faster user experience that directly impacts conversion.

---

Conclusion

BigCommerce SEO isn’t about surface-level tactics. It’s about understanding the platform’s architecture, its limitations, and the modern solutions available to work around them.

Stencil can absolutely perform well with proper optimization—but if you need global edge delivery, automatic next-gen imaging, and fine-grained rendering control, headless commerce becomes the clear path forward.

Regardless of which direction you choose, a technically sound BigCommerce stack becomes a powerful advantage: faster load times, higher search visibility, and a better foundation for long-term scalability.

---

If you're interested in having a BigCommerce storefront built for you at no cost (yes FREE) reach out to us. We offer free storefront setups for qualifying businesses when you enroll through the BigCommerce partner referral program (no extra cost to you).

Interested? Learn more here!